Thursday, November 19, 2026

SEE IT: Jury Notes Send Lindsay Clancy Case Into Chaos

Related

Jury notes from Lindsay Clancy’s triple‑murder trial expose a juror dispute that forced a mistrial.

Jury Notes Reveal Mistrial Chaos

The foreperson, a retired elementary school teacher, repeatedly warned Judge William Sullivan that a juror refused to apply the court’s reasonable‑doubt instruction.

“A member of the jury is unable to follow the instructions regarding reasonable doubt. How should we proceed?” the foreperson wrote, according to notes published Wednesday by Los Angeles Magazine.

She publicly criticized the prosecution and praised defense attorney Kevin Reddington just days after the September 4 mistrial.

The lone holdout juror denied the foreperson’s characterization, saying he had no reasonable doubt about Clancy’s guilt and favored conviction while the other eleven voted for acquittal.

“This is why we can not come to a unanimous decision,” the foreperson added in a second note, which LA Magazine also released.

During deliberations, Judge Sullivan individually asked each juror if they could follow his legal instructions; all, including the holdout, affirmed they could.

The judge denied Reddington’s request for further questioning of the holdout, citing risk of intruding on deliberations, and sent the jury back to continue.

Clancy’s legal team argued the judge should have investigated the allegation and replaced the holdout, but Sullivan ruled the notes reflected legitimate disagreement and that additional inquiry would violate jury independence.

The defense filed a petition Monday with the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, seeking reversal of Sullivan’s ruling and dismissal of the three remaining murder charges on double jeopardy grounds.

Clancy has admitted to killing her three children, asserting postpartum psychosis prevented criminal responsibility; her retrial is set for March 29, 2027.

Related: Lindsay Clancy Is Headed Back To Court As Judge Sets Retrial Date

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest article