Friday, November 20, 2026

Man Convicted Of Abusing Boys fights for infant son

Related

A 75-year-old former registered sex offender arranged a surrogacy that produced a child and is now appealing a custody denial, highlighting the risks of pregnancy commodification. The case unfolded in Texas and has drawn attention from child‑welfare advocates.

Statute Bypassed, Criminal History Obscured

Texas law since 2003 requires intended parents in a gestational agreement to be married; an unmarried individual cannot qualify. Kaplan, who was not married, asked the court to waive the home‑study requirement, and a judge initially approved the arrangement.

Kaplan, 75 at the time of the process, faced a high probability of death or incapacitation before the child reached driving age, raising concerns about the child’s long‑term care.

Public records show Kaplan’s 2009 Nebraska convictions for seven counts of child abuse and one count of false imprisonment involving adolescent boys; his attorney later withdrew, citing misrepresentation of his criminal history.

Only the Hospital Intervened

The surrogacy service was paid $50,000 to the gestational carrier, and neither party had a financial motive to scrutinize Kaplan’s background.

SM, the carrier, told Texas authorities she knew nothing of the criminal record and wanted no involvement or backlash.

On Oct. 31, 2025, Baylor Scott & White Medical Center–Lake Pointe intervened, prompting an emergency hearing. A judge canceled the earlier approval on Nov. 12, 2025, ruling that the sworn statement contained false information and ordered a home study and psychiatric evaluation if Kaplan pursued the agreement.

The child was born the following day; Texas DFPS took emergency custody that week, and genetic testing confirmed Kaplan as the biological father.

What This Case Reveals About Surrogacy

Advocacy groups such as Surrogacy Concern note a sharp rise in single, often older, men using surrogacy, creating systemic risks.

The Kaplan saga mirrors earlier incidents, including a household that lost 21 children after alleged abuse and pedophiles who obtained babies through surrogacy.

Even in Texas, where marriage is required and court approval is mandatory, legal safeguards were bypassed: a home‑study waiver was granted, the criminal record was missed until a hospital lawyer reviewed public records, and financial interests aligned against disclosure.

Had the hospital not acted, the approved order would have directed the hospital to give the newborn to Kaplan, list him as father on the birth certificate, and seal the file, leaving the child in the care of a registered sex offender whose prior victims were boys.

Kaplan testified that he had changed, but a jury terminated his parental rights in August 2026, citing endangerment and the child’s best interest, relying on his Nebraska convictions.

Texas DFPS retained legal custody; the child remains in foster care with documented medical needs.

Kaplan filed an appeal on Oct. 5, 2026, and continues to seek custody.

The case demonstrates that current surrogacy frameworks place children at unacceptable risk when adult desire, money, and incomplete information converge.

The author was not involved in the legal proceedings described.

Andrew D. Keetch is a Texas attorney and freelance writer.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest article