Lawsuit Challenges Newsom’s Blanket Clemency
California Governor Gavin Newsom plans to commute the death sentences of 548 inmates, igniting a lawsuit that questions his clemency authority.
The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation filed a suit in the California Supreme Court on Sunday, alleging Newsom failed to notify district attorneys and violated victims’ rights.
Newsom announced on November 5 that he intends to convert all 548 death sentences to life imprisonment without parole, pending legal steps.
Zack Smith, senior legal fellow at the Heritage Foundation, told Fox News Digital that Newsom is using his clemency power to override voter will, which repeatedly rejected death‑penalty abolition.
“The death penalty remains on the books, and California voters have rejected abolition five times,” Smith said. “Now Newsom is attempting to impose his own view through a mass commutation.”
Under the California Constitution, Newsom must secure recommendations from at least four Supreme Court justices before commuting the sentences of 382 inmates convicted of multiple felonies.
The foundation asks the court to immediately stay any implementation of the commutations pending review.

Anne Marie Schubert, president and CEO of CJLF, said the suit protects victims’ constitutional rights and ensures no governor is above the law.
Greg Totten, CEO of the California District Attorneys Association, warned that the governor’s failure to give required notice deprives prosecutors of the chance to present victim information.

San Luis Obispo County District Attorney Dan Dow called the proposal “a sickening abuse of power” that values killers’ lives over victims’ families.
If carried out, the action would be the largest mass commutation of death sentences in U.S. history, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.
Newsom previously imposed a 2019 moratorium on executions, leaving the death‑penalty statute intact while halting executions.
Democratic Governor‑elect Xavier Becerra pledged to extend the moratorium when he takes office, citing cost and racial disparities.
Attorney General Rob Bonta told the court Newsom will not formally commute any sentences until the Supreme Court acts, including inmates with single felony convictions.
Newsom’s office has not responded to inquiries, while the coalition of law enforcement leaders, victims’ rights groups, and district attorneys continues to press the case.
