A federal judge on Nov. 17 halted new DHS rules that would restrict internships and practical training for international students. Judge Julia Kobick in Massachusetts ruled the agency likely violated the Administrative Procedure Act.
Judge Blocks DHS Internship Rules
Kobick said DHS changed a 1991 policy allowing elective internships for credit without notice or explanation. She ignored reliance by schools and students.
The dispute involves curricular practical training. It lets F-1 visa holders train in internships tied to their studies.
Kobick issued a nationwide injunction. She barred the rule from applying to the plaintiffs, their members, schools, and their employees and students.
She said the plaintiffs—AAU, Presidents’ Alliance, Immigration, Independent Colleges and NAFSA—are likely to win. Their case is strong.
She warned schools face immediate financial loss, program redesign costs, risk of losing student authorization, and potential criminal liability for officials. These harms outweigh the government’s rationale.
DHS said the restrictions aim to ensure training meets federal standards. It argues many approvals were not integral to an established curriculum.
The Aug. 12 directive increased scrutiny after a rise in authorizations. It disrupted fall internships and prompted universities to revise academic requirements.
Columbia denied fall training to over 120 students. Grinnell lost 13 internship opportunities, and Cornell and Michigan State reported student attrition.
Washington University said curriculum changes diverted faculty from other duties. Dartmouth and Vanderbilt warned of a chilling effect and fear of prosecution.
The government countered that the memos merely clarified existing regulations. It said schools could not reasonably rely on informal guidance.
Kobick rejected that argument. She noted the 1991 regulation and guidance allowed elective credit training, and agencies must acknowledge changes and consider reliance.
The ruling leaves the restrictions blocked while the case proceeds. Kobick found the plaintiffs likely succeeded on the claim that the directives were arbitrary and capricious.
