Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Maine Judge Rules School Board Discriminates Against Pines Church

Related

A federal judge has ruled the Hermon School Committee discriminated against The Pines Church by denying a yearlong lease for Sunday services, violating the First Amendment and Maine’s public accommodations law. The decision marks a clear rebuke of religious bias in a public school setting.

Judge Cites Religious Bias

Pastor Matt Gioia asked the committee in 2022 for a yearlong lease at Hermon High School, but the panel offered only a month‑to‑month arrangement and ultimately rejected the request. The judge found that committee members Christopher McLaughlin, Stephanie Oiler and Karen Shorey based their vote on the church’s religious identity.

Committee member Christopher McLaughlin sent questions through then‑Superintendent Micah Grant, probing the church’s stance on diversity, same‑sex marriage, abortion and transgender issues. Grant forwarded those queries to Gioia, prompting the committee to weigh the request against perceived cultural concerns.

Walker concluded that while Superintendent Grant showed no personal bias, at least three committee members were improperly influenced by the church’s faith‑based message. He wrote that the decision reflected a ‘bad motive’ under Supreme Court precedent, confirming a violation of the plaintiffs’ First Amendment rights.

Injunction Denied, Policy Unchallenged

The court rejected the church’s request for a permanent injunction, saying the existing rental policy was not shown unconstitutional and the plaintiffs failed to prove irreparable harm. Walker emphasized that the violation was limited to the committee’s actions, not the policy itself.

District Reviews Decision

Hermon School Superintendent Barbara Sargent said the district is reviewing the ruling and will adjust its procedures. She affirmed that the department’s commitment to students remains unchanged and that the decision will not distract from its educational mission.

Advocacy Group Praises Ruling

Advocates for Faith & Freedom hailed the judgment as a victory for religious liberty. President Bob Tyler said the court recognized that public schools cannot exclude churches simply because of their faith, affirming constitutional neutrality.

The Pines Church and its legal representatives have not yet responded to inquiries. Fox News Digital has not received comment from the church or Advocates for Faith & Freedom.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest article