Justice Clarence Thomas urged the Supreme Court to examine state bans on carrying firearms in “sensitive places,” declaring the restrictions unconstitutional. He made the statement in the Court’s Monday order list, which denied certiorari in Novotny v. Moore.
Thomas Cites Historical Tradition
The Court’s Monday order list denied certiorari in Novotny v. Moore, a challenge to Maryland’s prohibitions on firearms in public demonstrations, mass transit, health facilities and other venues. Thomas wrote that he concurs with the denial because each Maryland statute reflects a distinct historical tradition, making the petitioners’ broad challenge “complicated.”
He warned that the restrictions lack historical grounding and called on the Court to resolve the issue in a future case limited to the specific “sensitive places” at question. He emphasized that expanding the definition of “sensitive places” would undermine the right to publicly carry arms for self‑defense.
Bruen Framework Shapes Debate
The 2022 NYSRPA v. Bruen decision established a two‑step test: courts must first determine whether the regulated conduct falls within the Second Amendment’s text, then assess whether the regulation aligns with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. The majority held that any regulation must be consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.
Thomas noted that the Court has previously recognized a narrow tradition of restricting carry in certain “sensitive places,” but argued that expanding that category to all public gathering spots would “eviscerate” the right to bear arms for self‑defense. He argued that the historical tradition was narrowly confined to places such as legislatures, polling places and courthouses.
He added that many modern “sensitive places” bear little resemblance to legislatures, polling places or courthouses, and that their cumulative effect blocks law‑abiding citizens from carrying arms in venues for eating, drinking, recreation, amusement or free speech. These bans, he said, effectively prohibit law‑abiding citizens from exercising their ordinary self‑defense rights wherever people gather for eating, drinking, recreation, amusement or free speech.
Thomas concluded with “serious doubts” about the legality of these bans under the historical tradition, urging the Court to consider the issue in an appropriate case. His remarks signal that the Court may soon confront the issue in a case that directly addresses the constitutionality of such bans.
Upcoming Cases
The Court will hear oral arguments in Viramontes v. Cook County and Grant v. Higgins, which together address the legality of bans on AR‑15 style semiautomatic rifles. The consolidated litigation will determine whether AR‑15 style rifles are protected by the Second Amendment.
Shawn Fleetwood, staff writer for The Federalist and a University of Mary Washington graduate, received the 2025 Dao Prize for Investigative Journalism. His work appears in RealClearPolitics and RealClearHealth. Follow him on Twitter @ShawnFleetwood.
