Assemblywoman Gallagher Calls Shoplifting a “Biological Need” Amidst Rising Crime Concerns
Assemblywoman Emily Gallagher (D‑50th District) told reporters on Thursday that shoplifting essential items such as toothpaste is not a crime but a biological need, igniting a firestorm of criticism.
Speaking outside Manhattan Criminal Court with fellow left‑wing officials and Court Watch NYC activists, Gallagher cited a review of 360 arraignments over four days in which more than half involved misdemeanor offenses, arguing that the cases reflect poverty‑driven theft of necessities.
“Most of what we saw were crimes of poverty—people stealing toothpaste, soap, items they need,” Gallagher said. “If you are stealing those things, you need them.”
She accused the city of protecting corporate giants like CVS and Walgreens at the expense of struggling residents, claiming the real crime is the city’s wealth disparity.
Gallagher, a member of the Democratic Socialists of America, advocates “treatment‑not‑jail” outcomes for shoplifters, despite NYPD data showing retail theft down 14.7% and petit larceny down 5.4% through Aug. 9.
Critics on the street responded sharply. Rev. Susan Webb, 68, said, “It is foolish to think one should not be punished for stealing; it is a crime.”
Jeanette Mack, a 49‑year‑old academic adviser, added that Gallagher’s policies “enable” shoplifters and create a sense of entitlement.
Republican Councilwoman Vickie Paladino warned that the rhetoric “obfuscates reality” and “enables” criminal activity, while former Queens Councilman Robert Holden called Gallagher “a major dope.”
Councilwoman Joann Ariola (R‑Queens) warned that advocating for theft will push more businesses to close, noting that “policies that Gallagher is pushing are exactly what’s driving so many of them away.”
Mayor Zohran Mamdani, another self‑identified socialist, has pledged to end “broken windows” policing of minor offenses such as graffiti and fare evasion, a stance that aligns with Gallagher’s broader agenda.
