America’s Christian landscape is splintering as progressive and nationalist factions each claim Jesus for their political agenda.
Progressive and Nationalist Claims on Faith
In Texas, incoming Democratic Senator James Talarico says his Christian faith drives support for abortion rights, asserting that “Jesus never talks about abortion.”
Conversely, pastor Joel Webbon gathered 1,200 activists at a “Christ Is King” event, where speakers such as Alex Jones, James Fishback and Nick Fuentes promoted a white, male, Christian vision of the state.
Both movements argue that the Son of God would align with their coalitions, but each distorts the Gospel.
Interpreting Scripture
Talarico’s claim that the Bible is silent on abortion ignores passages that uphold the dignity of life, according to Catholic teaching, which bases its stance on the Ten Commandments and New Testament ethics.
Webbon’s assertion that “White people are not going to go quietly into the night” contradicts Revelation 7:9, which describes a multicultural multitude before God’s throne, scholars note.
Garcia, host of the YouTube show “We The People,” says both sides let ideology decide which scripture to emphasize.
Religious Liberty and the First Amendment
The First Amendment protects the right of both Talarico and Webbon to express their beliefs, but it also safeguards the freedom to critique them, Garcia adds.
Garcia stresses that religious liberty allows passionate debate without government endorsement of any particular interpretation.
Hope Amid Division
Garcia observes that his own church remains filled with families attending Sunday Mass, athletes citing God in interviews, and everyday believers acting compassionately.
He converted to Catholicism not to advance a political agenda but to embrace a timeless moral framework that calls him to be a better human.
Garcia cites the Parable of the Talents, urging believers to steward the Gospel rather than reshape it to fit political goals.
He remains confident that Christianity, having survived two millennia of persecution, will not be undone by a Texas senator or online chatroom extremists.
Garcia concludes that the solution lies in emulating Jesus, not in molding Jesus to fit personal ambitions.
Gates Garcia is the host of the YouTube show and podcast “We The People.” Follow him on Instagram and X @GatesGarciaFL.
