Cato Institute senior fellow David J. Bier told Congress that tougher immigration enforcement would paradoxically fuel illegal crossings, arguing that a minimal increase in legal pathways would curb the problem.
Bier’s Argument on Legal Pathways
“Our immigrant coworkers, neighbors, friends, and family want to contribute to this country legally. Let them. Fix legal immigration,” Bier said in a congressional hearing.
He added, “Imagine if just three percent of gun sales were permitted. Many in this room, myself included, would call that gun prohibition. But that’s how few immigrants seeking permanent legal status in the United States through the proper processes actually get approved in a year.”
Nowrasteh’s Counterpoint on Borders
Alex Nowrasteh, also of the Cato Institute, replied that “borders are supposed to keep other governments out, not other people,” according to a November 15 tweet.
He dismissed criticism as “bot” activity, noting that detractors posted non‑sequitur comments about criminals and personal attacks.
Security Concerns Linked to Border Policies
A September watchdog report identified extensive vetting failures among migrants admitted after the Biden administration’s Afghanistan withdrawal.
Rahmunalla Lakanwal, a migrant who entered under the program, shot and killed Spec. Sarah Beckstrom, 20, and Staff Sgt. Andrew Wolfe in Washington, D.C., in November 2023.
Other individuals linked to the same influx face separate criminal charges: Luqmaan Kahn arrested for plotting a mass shooting, Jaan Shah Safi for ISIS‑K support, Mohammad Dawood Alokozay for bomb plots in Fort Worth, and Nazira Haji Zada deported for an Election Day ISIS‑inspired attack.
Since 2021, the number of Chinese nationals encountered at the southern border has surged, reaching 21,000 in 2023, many of them single adult males of military age.
In 2023, authorities uncovered an illegal Chinese bio‑lab in California handling HIV, hepatitis and herpes agents, and a Chinese national was arrested for photographing aircraft at a Nebraska Air Force base.
Additional incidents include the April arrest of a Chinese citizen for smuggling E. coli and June arrests of two individuals transporting Fusarium graminearum, a toxic foodborne pathogen.
Fiscal Impact of Illegal Immigration
Taxpayer funds have been allocated to house and feed illegal aliens, including FEMA disaster aid, which critics say displaced American hurricane victims from hotel accommodations in North Carolina.
Conclusion
The claim that borders are merely symbolic is “laughable,” Nowrasteh asserted, while his opponents argue that national security and fiscal responsibility demand stricter enforcement.
