Saturday, November 21, 2026

DOJ Backs OpenAI in AI Copyright Battle with News Media

Related

AI copyright battle threatens Trump’s agenda and tests core legal principle. Major news outlets have sued OpenAI and Microsoft, claiming massive copyright violations.

DOJ Backs OpenAI in Copyright Lawsuit

The Department of Justice filed a statement of interest supporting OpenAI, embracing an expansive view of fair use that would let AI companies access copyrighted works freely for commercial training, without seeking licenses or paying creators.

DOJ officials say requiring licenses would raise costs for developers, hinder competition, and jeopardize U.S. AI leadership and national security.

Critics note the stance favors large corporations over smaller startups and runs counter to the administration’s own AI framework, which calls for balanced consideration of both innovation and creators’ rights.

The White House AI blueprint acknowledges valid arguments on both sides of the copyright debate, while the G20’s Carolina Principles for Emerging Technologies stresses the essential role of copyright in supporting creators.

Industry Pushback and Legislative Response

Music industry groups warn that AI “stealing” the charts could undermine artists, while several AI startups argue that paying for training data offers more reliable access, reduces legal risk, and improves model quality.

Large AI companies, which can afford licensing fees, have little ground to complain about costs, experts say, and paying for content would help develop legitimate licensing markets.

Constitutional concerns arise: intellectual property remains property, and the government cannot appropriate it without just compensation, a principle that underpins U.S. law.

If courts accept the DOJ’s broad fair‑use claim, creators may see fewer incentives to produce new books, articles, research, films and songs, eventually starving AI systems of high‑quality training material.

Policymakers should let the courts decide case by case rather than endorse a blanket exemption, according to the administration’s own AI framework.

A bipartisan bill, the CLEAR Act, introduced by Sens. Adam Schiff and John Curtis, would require AI developers to disclose the copyrighted works used in each generative‑AI model’s training dataset, giving creators clearer insight and a path to compensation.

Targeted reform, not blanket fair‑use arguments, offers a balanced way to protect innovation while respecting creators’ rights, experts conclude.

Coke Morgan Stewart is president and CEO of the Council for Innovation Promotion and the former deputy under secretary of Commerce for intellectual property and deputy director of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest article